The Archaeologist as a Detective
Updated: 4 days ago
Murder mysteries and archaeology have a lot in common — both rely on fragmentary, erratic clues pieced together into a cohesive narrative about the past. In both cases, thorough, detailed observations are bridged by leaps of imagination or intuition to draw inferences about the past, its people and their behaviour.
Several mystery authors have taken a stab (sometimes literally) at creating archaeology-based murder stories. Michael Crichton (Timeline), Kate Moss (Labyrinth), Elizabeth Peters/Barbara Mertz (Amelia Peabody series), and Aaron Elkins (Gideon Oliver series) are some popular authors and works in a done-to-death genre.
As strange as fiction can be, here are some intriguing archaeological whodunnits. The mummified remains of Rameses III, Egypt’s second pharaoh, have grisly slashes across the throat. Since then, ancient documents like the Judicial Papyrus of Turin have named the guilty parties, including one of his wives, Tiye, and her son, Pentawere. Yet archaeologists cannot be certain that the throat slashes were what killed the pharaoh.
The death of Attila the Hun, ruler of the Eastern and Central Europe’s Hunnic Empire from 440 to 453 AD, was attributed to death by a severe nosebleed on the night of one of his many weddings, yet archaeologists believe it may have been his wife Gudrun, in the bedroom, with a dagger.
The Royal Cemetery of Ur, an ancient Sumerian city, contains 74 attendants, 6 males and 68 women, some buried with their tools of trade such as musical instruments or spears, which has archaeologists questioning whether this was ritual sacrifice or a voluntary death rite. It wasn’t just archaeologists who fell prey to the allure of the royal tombs at Ur, Agatha Christie did too.
In Part 1: How archaeology inspired murder, Gowri N Kishore of About Murder, She Wrote examined how archaeology shaped Christie’s life and work, with several storylines and characters inspired by her time on the digs. I wrote about the archaeological significance of the locations featured in Christie’s novels.
In Part 2, we’ll explore how archaeologists are detectives in their own right, the clues they unearth, the painstaking techniques of cleaning artefacts, and the inferences they draw about past people and places.
Perhaps nobody saw the connection between archaeology and detection better than Agatha Christie herself, because she wrote a delightful poem about it!
Her archaeological memoir Come, Tell Me How You Live opens with a parody of ‘Haddock’s Eyes’, a poem from Lewis Carroll’s Through the Looking-Glass. In the original poem, an “aged, aged man” who’s “a-sitting on a gate” tells the Knight all about his work. In Agatha’s version, ‘an erudite young man’ (no doubt a stand-in for her archaeologist husband Max Mallowan) who’s ‘a-sitting on a Tell’ (a tell is a term for an archaeologically significant mound or hill) tells her all about his work while she plots murder in her head!

A Trail of Clues
Hercule Poirot: My friend, we have not been fortunate. The murderer has not been obliging. He has not dropped for us the cuff link, the cigarette end, the cigar ash - or, in the case of a woman, the handkerchief, the lipstick, or the hair slide.
Death on the Nile, Agatha Christie.
If you’ve read enough murder mysteries, or watched forensic crime shows, you’d be familiar with the trail of clues that detectives follow. Muddy footprints, blood stains, a saucer of milk with no cat, a half-burnt note, warm embers in the fireplace…the list goes on. Archaeologists, too, follow a trail of clues — artefacts that people created, modified or used; tools for hunting, gathering, farming, and warfare mark the progress of civilization; human remains such as teeth hint at what they ate, and dented skulls or broken bones indicate how they died; written records in papyrus, wood, or stone document daily lives; and monuments mark key historic events such as victory, religious dominion, or death.
In murder mysteries, a freshly dug patch of earth is often where the body is buried. Archaeologists rely on a variety of clues to decide where to dig or, in the case of shipwrecks, where to dive. Some sites are found by accident; some are revealed during construction or after natural disasters. For others, archaeologists look for clues in historic records or local stories, or capture aerial photographs to identify mounds or tells — a hillock that betrays successive human settlements. Sometimes, artefacts like stone tools, glass, jewellery, midden soil (where ancient garbage mouldered), or parts of buried walls, floors, or foundations hint at where humans once lived.
Real-world detectives spend a lot of time on evidence gathering, and paperwork before they can make guesses about what happened in the past, just like archaeologists. The painstaking laborious processes of gathering the ‘clues’, cleaning, classifying and categorising them, has made archaeology seem rather dull to the outsider.
In Murder in Mesopotamia, narrated from Nurse Leatheran’s perspective, we read about two sides to archaeology — the layman’s incomprehension when she visits the dig, and her begrudging acknowledgement of the magic of the process:
“Afterwards Dr Leidner and Mr Mercado cleaned some pottery, pouring a solution of hydrochloric acid over it. One pot went a lovely plum colour and a pattern of bulls’ horns came out on another one. It was really quite magical. All the dried mud that no washing would remove sort of foamed and boiled away.”
Yet there’s more excitement in store beyond watching paint and pots dry! For archaeologists, putting the clues together to understand human history is the most exciting part. It starts with asking questions. Who created these artefacts, and for what purpose? Why did they choose to live here? How did they survive? What did they eat? What did they wear? How did they interact with the landscapes around them? What has been preserved, and what has been lost?
Even with fragmentary remains, archaeologists have deciphered so much about past civilizations, often with wild leaps of imagination and drawing parallels to human lifestyles today, which aren’t as different from what we imagine. Let’s follow the trails of clues, to understand how archaeological finds have helped us reconstruct the past, with some parallels in crime fiction.
Artefacts as Clues
We often read about the more sensational archaeological discoveries — a gold dagger, a diadem of gems, a royal tomb, or a hoard of inscribed coins — yet these are few and far in between. The most common artefacts found at excavations are shards and sherds. Shards are broken bits of glass. Sherds are broken bits of pottery or clay, uncooked, or fired, glazed or unglazed.
“The prehistorian is witness to the sad fact that the ideals perish, and it is the cutlery of a society that are imperishable.”
Glyn Daniel, archaeologist.
Artefacts are classified as portable, meaningful objects created, modified or used by people in the past. These include stone tablets, armour, sarcophagi, jewellery, coins, items of personal adornment, religious figurines, keys, musical instruments, tools, among others — most of which illuminate the lives of common folk, rather than a privileged few.

Parallels to crime fiction: in murder mysteries, portable human artefacts such as a missing key, half-burned letters, a mismatched teacup, a misaligned vase, a scented, monogrammed handkerchief, or blotting paper can serve as clues. Many artefacts also feature as murder weapons, poisoned pages of Aristotle’s Poetics, heavy bookends, a scarf or a cord, toxic medicines, and bizarrely, even a typewriter with missing keys (what were you thinking, Stephen King?). I think a crime writer must spend a morbid amount of time imagining almost any object within reach as a plausible murder weapon!
Tools as Clues
“There were big things he called querns, and pestles and celts and stone axes, and more broken bits of pottery with queer patterns on them than I’ve ever seen all at once.” Murder in Mesopotamia, Agatha Christie.
A quern is a stone tool that served as a murder weapon in Christie’s novel, yet served a more prosaic purpose through history: grinding grain. Much like a pestle, querns — a pair of grinder and grindstone, often with a hole — have been used since the Neolithic era. Finding querns at archaeological sites was evidence of agriculture, as harvested cereal cannot be eaten with its tough cellulose shell. Querns and pestles evolved to grind cereal into flour, which could be used for a wide range of foods. The earliest discoveries of a quern have been from Abu Hureyra, Syria, dated to 9,000 BC — with human remains exhibiting skeletal deformities associated with prolonged quern usage. After all, it takes a lot of effort to work the quern.
A celt (pronounced kelt), not to be mistaken with the Celtic tribe, is a long, thin, polished stone or bronze haft fixed into a wooden handle that can serve as an axe or a chisel. In prehistoric times, celts were used for forest clearing, woodworking, and soil tilling. As celts served to clear forests for preferred wild grasses, their presence at archaeological sites is thought to signify a dietary transition from large mammals to cultivated crops. Celts are also considered to be signs of expansion — as settlements expanded along river valleys, or around waterbodies, they felled nearby forests for timber, firewood and agriculture.
The earliest stone axes have been excavated in Australia, dating back to over 40,000 years. Other findings include axes from the Japanese archipelago (32,000-38,000 years old), and southern China (19,000-21,000 years old). Over time, axes evolved into a bewildering range of shapes and sizes, using different materials, with varied techniques for affixing handles. Archaeological studies interpret axes as a tool used by early farming communities that revolutionized civilization as we know it. They not only represent a transition from hunter-gatherers to cultivators, but as stones were sourced from far and wide, axes hint at a nexus of exchange and trade in prehistoric societies.
Through the metal ages, civilizations learned to cast and engrave axes. Metal axes could be used for heavy stone work, such as dolmen or chambered tomb building, or to erect sites like the Stonehenge. As stone and metal axe design evolved, they could be wielded in battles, and are evidence of warring, conquering tribes. In some instances, polished or finely-made axes that do not show much sign of wear, may have been status symbols.
Across East and Southeast Asia, axes were used often for ceremonial purposes, with medicinal or healing properties ascribed to them. An unusual bronze axe dated between 1 to 500 AD, was unearthed on Roti island in the Lesser Sunda Islands in eastern Indonesia. It shows a human figure with a rather large head, big eyes and outstretched arms. Theories abound about the anthropomorphic figure, with several symbolic and religious interpretations.
Archaeologists believe that the physical demands of stone-flaking — the process by which stone tools were made — led to evolutionary changes in the human hand, enabling dexterity and precision. Stone tools provided the evolutionary advantage over clawed and toothed predators, for humans to survive and thrive in the wilderness, before building a refuge in settlements. The forethought needed to craft and wield the tools sharpened our cognitive skills. For over 3.3 million years, humans and their ancestors have been reworking those primitive tools, with ingenuity and purpose, to usher in this Age of Technology.
Read more on how stone tools offer clues to early human civilizations:.
Parallels in crime fiction: a dagger, a knife, a pistol, or gun are common tools that feature as murder weapons in crime fiction. The board game Cluedo, takes it a notch up with a candlestick, a lead pipe, a wrench as murder weapon options. More daring authors have chosen telephone cords, sports equipment, a pointy umbrella, a set of keys, and even a lapel pin. Just like with artefacts, creative-minded murderers can use a variety of tools in a pinch.

Of all the similarities between archaeology and the art of detection, human remains offer the most tantalising clues to the past. Gowri N Kishore of About Murder, She Wrote explores that in this section.
Human Remains as Clues
Mystery writers have used human remains in their tales as early as the late 19th century; for instance, the Sherlock Holmes stories of Arthur Conan Doyle. In The Adventure of the Cardboard Box, Sherlock Holmes deduces the identity of both victim and murderer by examining a pair of severed ears (mismatched, btw!) He even boasts of having written two monographs on the unique features of the human ear for the Anthropological Journal.
Things get a lot more believable with R. Austin Freeman’s Dr Thorndyke stories, written in the early 1900s. Dr Thorndyke is a medical jurispractitioner, trained in both law and medicine. Given his background, much of his detection relies on examining bodily clues and drawing inferences from them.
Bones and teeth rather than bloodstains feature more often in the early stories. These are hard, durable structures that are not easily destroyed. They take time to decompose and show predictable signs of development and ageing, making them excellent sources of evidence. In one story, Dr Thorndyke examines anomalies in a recovered skull to infer the victim’s height, build, and muscularity. In other stories, teeth and dental work help him identify victims or rule out suspects.
Sometimes, the clues lie not in the teeth themselves but with the dentist. Agatha Christie, Dorothy L. Sayers, Marjorie Allingham and other Golden Age writers have all written stories in which dental work found on a body offers clues about the person’s identity, life and even time of death. For instance, someone is supposed to have died in 1923, but an examination of the body reveals a dental filling of a type that was available in England only after 1925. This gives the investigators a clue to what really happened.
Perhaps because of her training as a pharmacy dispenser and a nurse, Agatha Christie is especially free in her use of bodily clues, sometimes even when there’s no body yet. These include everything from unusual hairfall and the shape of someone’s knees, and the half-bitten fingernails on a corpse.
Parallels in archaeology: In his memoirs, Max Mallowan describes several instances where the discovery of human remains helped archaeologists piece together aspects of ancient life.
At Ur, the Royal Cemetery excavated by Leonard Woolley revealed elaborate tombs, including one in which 74 people had apparently been buried alive alongside their ruler. This told them about the funerary rituals, human sacrifice and social hierarchy of Early Dynastic Mesopotamia. In Arpachiya, archaeologists found several bodies and painted pottery arranged against the walls of certain buildings; Max writes that the buildings were likely to be sacred resting grounds for inhumation. Evidence of a mass burial found at Nimrud, when considered alongside records of the palace’s destruction around the same time, helped to reconstruct the circumstances of the Median and Babylonian assault on the Assyrian city.

In both archaeology and detective work, physical clues rarely tell a complete story on their own. The investigator has to use deduction and a certain amount of imagination to fill in the gaps. A fictional detective begins with uncertainty and a collection of fragmentary details. Why is there a bloodstain on the carpet near the washstand? Whose footprints are those in the flower bed? Who could have entered and left without being seen? (S)he builds hypotheses, tests them against the available evidence, and gradually reconstructs the crime, much as an archaeologist does.
In his memoir, Max describes how Leonard Woolley loved leading visitors around the ruins, embellishing actual evidence with stories from his fertile imagination. For example, he would say, “This is the headmaster’s house. Take care of the bottom step. It’s much too high. There was once a wooden step in front of it, but this has long ago perished. You see, the owner had to have the maximum possible rise before the turn of the stairs…in that way he was able to avoid bumping his head. Now take a look at the roof… (everyone stared up at the empty sky) I know you cannot see it, but we know everything about it that matters. The evidence is mostly on the floor in front of you.”
Woolley was able to paint a vivid picture of an entire house and a settlement, based on the probability of what could have happened based on things like wind direction, rainfall, land slopes, records, and topography. Max writes that this tour was “exhilarating, and if sometimes we were taken by the hand and led gently up the garden path, what a wonderful path it was!”
Snarky!
I can’t help thinking that Hercule Poirot’s gathering of suspects and laying out one theory after another before dramatically making the grand denouement is not so different from Woolley’s guided tours. Both involve a flair for storytelling and showmanship; the ability to make an audience see—and believe—an entire sequence of events based on a handful of clues.
The difference is that fictional detectives and us readers are usually rewarded with a definitive solution. But archaeologists often have to accept that some parts of the story will always remain beyond their reach!
False Starts and Fitting Facts
Colonel Race: “It often seems to me that’s all detective work is, wiping out your false starts and beginning again.”
Hercule Poirot: “Yes, it is very true, that. And it is just what some people will not do. They conceive a certain theory, and everything has to fit into that theory. If one little fact will not fit it, they throw it aside. But it is always the facts that will not fit in that are significant.”
Death on the Nile, Agatha Christie.
As inspired as the leaps of imagination are to bridge the gap between clues and the past, here’s a cautionary note. Our imaginations are just as susceptible to biases, and the consequences of adding up the clues to arrive at a false conclusion, are all too real for both detective and archaeologist.
A dark, well-known example is Erich von Däniken’s ‘Ancient Alien’ hypothesis, which attributed grand monuments to extraterrestrial intervention, rather than acknowledge the architectural achievements of so-called ‘backward, non-white’ peoples. Similarly, scholars with a Western-centric perspective suggested that far-flung Pacific islands were populated by mere accident, casting doubt on the navigational expertise and extensive voyages of the Polynesian people.
The field of archaeology would do well to heed Poirot’s words, it is always the facts that will not fit in that are significant.
This incredible 2-part series wouldn’t have been possible without Gowri N Kishore of About Murder, She Wrote — a brilliant Substack dedicated to detective stories and murder mysteries. Gowri writes reflective pieces and analyses of the genre, specific works, and forgotten authors, as well as short stories and book/film/show/podcast recommendations.



